Expectation versus Reality: The Impact of Utility on Emotional Outcomes after Returning Individualized Genetic Research Results in Pediatric Rare Disease Research, a Qualitative Interview Study
MetadataShow full item record
CitationCacioppo, Cara N., Ariel E. Chandler, Meghan C. Towne, Alan H. Beggs, and Ingrid A. Holm. 2016. “Expectation versus Reality: The Impact of Utility on Emotional Outcomes after Returning Individualized Genetic Research Results in Pediatric Rare Disease Research, a Qualitative Interview Study.” PLoS ONE 11 (4): e0153597. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0153597. http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0153597.
AbstractPurpose Much information on parental perspectives on the return of individual research results (IRR) in pediatric genomic research is based on hypothetical rather than actual IRR. Our aim was to understand how the expected utility to parents who received IRR on their child from a genetic research study compared to the actual utility of the IRR received. Methods: We conducted individual telephone interviews with parents who received IRR on their child through participation in the Manton Center for Orphan Disease Research Gene Discovery Core (GDC) at Boston Children’s Hospital (BCH). Results: Five themes emerged around the utility that parents expected and actually received from IRR: predictability, management, family planning, finding answers, and helping science and/or families. Parents expressing negative or mixed emotions after IRR return were those who did not receive the utility they expected from the IRR. Conversely, parents who expressed positive emotions were those who received as much or greater utility than expected. Conclusions: Discrepancies between expected and actual utility of IRR affect the experiences of parents and families enrolled in genetic research studies. An informed consent process that fosters realistic expectations between researchers and participants may help to minimize any negative impact on parents and families.
Citable link to this pagehttp://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:26860067
- HMS Scholarly Articles 
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Two Variants of the C-Reactive Protein Gene Are Associated with Risk of Pre-Eclampsia in an American Indian Population Best, Lyle G.; Saxena, Richa; Anderson, Cindy M.; Barnes, Michael R.; Hakonarson, Hakon; Falcon, Gilbert; Martin, Candelaria; Castillo, Berta Almoguera; Karumanchi, Ananth; Keplin, Kylie; Pearson, Nichole; Lamb, Felicia; Bercier, Shellee; Keating, Brendan J. (Public Library of Science, 2013)Background: The etiology of pre-eclampsia (PE) is unknown; but it is accepted that normal pregnancy represents a distinctive challenge to the maternal immune system. C-reactive protein is a prominent component of the innate ...
Genetic Susceptible Locus in NOTCH2 Interacts with Arsenic in Drinking Water on Risk of Type 2 Diabetes Pan, Wen-Chi; Kile, Molly L.; Seow, Wei Jie; Lin, Xihong; Quamruzzaman, Quazi; Rahman, Mahmuder; Mahiuddin, Golam; Mostofa, Golam; Lu, Quan; Christiani, David C. (Public Library of Science, 2013)Background: Chronic exposure to arsenic in drinking water is associated with increased risk of type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) but the underlying molecular mechanism remains unclear. Objectives: This study evaluated the ...
A Large Scale Gene-Centric Association Study of Lung Function in Newly-Hired Female Cotton Textile Workers with Endotoxin Exposure Zhang, Ruyang; Zhao, Yang; Chu, Minjie; Mehta, Amar Jayant; Wei, Yongyue; Liu, Yao; Xun, Pengcheng; Bai, Jianling; Yu, Hao; Su, Li; Zhang, Hongxi; Hu, Zhibin; Shen, Hongbing; Chen, Feng; Christiani, David C. (Public Library of Science, 2013)Background: Occupational exposure to endotoxin is associated with decrements in pulmonary function, but how much variation in this association is explained by genetic variants is not well understood. Objective: We aimed ...