Essays on Healthcare Provider Markets
MetadataShow full item record
CitationCarroll, Caitlin. 2019. Essays on Healthcare Provider Markets. Doctoral dissertation, Harvard University, Graduate School of Arts & Sciences.
AbstractThis dissertation consists of three chapters that investigate the productivity of health care providers.
Chapter 1 studies hospital closure and the supply of healthcare in rural markets. Hospital closure can be welfare improving if it reallocates patients to more efficient facilities but can also lead to treatment delay and worsened health outcomes. I find support for both sides of this debate. Using a difference-in-differences analysis of Medicare claims, I exploit variation in the effects of hospital closure within local markets: I compare enrollees who lost their closest hospital as a result of closure to enrollees who lost their second closest hospital, as a result of the same closure. I show that rural hospital closure led to both a decrease in Medicare spending and an increase in mortality among enrollees with time-sensitive health conditions. I study implications of forestalling hospital closure in the context of the Critical Access Hospital (CAH) program, a large-scale payment reform that increased Medicare revenues for nearly half of all rural hospitals. I show that the CAH program led to a reduction in hospital closures and an improvement in mortality, but the program’s expenditures were substantial relative to these effects.
Chapter 2 (with David Cutler and Anupam Jena) studies the influence of medical malpractice liability on physician behavior. While a substantial literature has studied the influence of malpractice pressure on physician behavior, existing research has not found that malpractice concerns influence physicians to any great extent. However, these studies generally focus on variation in state laws governing malpractice exposure. In this project, we test how physicians respond to malpractice allegations made against them —both those that are successful and those that are not. We study the impact of malpractice reports on the practice patterns of Emergency Department physicians, exploiting variation in the timing of unexpected malpractice allegations across doctors. We find that physician labor supply decreases after malpractice allegations and that this reduction is persistent over time. Our results are driven by intensive margin responses, specifically that physicians reduce the number of discharges they oversee, but maintain practice in the state. We also find that physicians increase total charges per discharge by after malpractice allegations. Lastly, we explore whether physicians respond optimally to malpractice allegations, testing whether physicians change their behavior according to the information content of the claim.
Chapter 3 (with Michael Chernew, A. Mark Fendrick, Joseph Thompson and Sherri Rose) studies how physicians respond to financial incentives imposed by episode-based payment (EBP), which encourages lower spending and improved quality for an entire episode of care. Specifically, we study the impact of the Arkansas Health Care Payment Improvement Initiative, a multi-payer program that requires providers to enter into EBP arrangements for perinatal care, covering the majority of births in the state. Unlike fee-for-service reimbursement, EBP holds physicians responsible for all care within a discrete episode, rewarding physicians for efficient use of their own services and for efficient management of other health care inputs. In a difference-in-differences analysis of commercial claims, we find that perinatal spending in Arkansas decreased overall under EBP, compared to surrounding states. The decrease was driven by reduced spending on non-physician health care inputs, specifically the prices paid for inpatient facility care. We additionally find a limited improvement in quality of care under EBP.
Citable link to this pagehttp://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:42029553
- FAS Theses and Dissertations 
Contact administrator regarding this item (to report mistakes or request changes)