A “Moraliste Moment”?: Ethics in Eighteenth-Century French Moralist Writing from Vauvenargues to Joubert
View/ Open
12-05-22 Barfield PhD thesis.pdf (1.402Mb)
Access Status
Full text of the requested work is not available in DASH at this time ("restricted access"). For more information on restricted deposits, see our FAQ.Author
Barfield, Matthew David
Metadata
Show full item recordCitation
Barfield, Matthew David. 2022. A “Moraliste Moment”?: Ethics in Eighteenth-Century French Moralist Writing from Vauvenargues to Joubert. Doctoral dissertation, Harvard University Graduate School of Arts and Sciences.Abstract
“A Moraliste Moment” examines eighteenth-century French moraliste writing: aphoristic texts studying human nature and social and political behavior. While scholars have usuallytreated the late seventeenth century as the zenith of moraliste writing’s quality and influence in
France, I explore why there was a second flourishing of moraliste writing during the eighteenth
century, and what this moment’s significance was for our understanding of moral thought in the French Enlightenment.
I study a corpus of moraliste texts by four authors spanning from the 1740s to the 1820s: the Marquis de Vauvenargues; Nicolas Chamfort; Antoine de Rivarol; and Joseph Joubert. I
further compare these texts to the works of seventeenth-century moralistes, as well as to the those of eighteenth-century philosophes.
I argue that the eighteenth-century moralistes chose to return to the aphorism genre,
creating a new “moraliste moment,” in order to elaborate an alternative ethical perspective to
that of the Enlightenment philosophes. I contend that, influenced by their seventeenth-century
predecessors, eighteenth-century moralistes use the genre to present a negative moral critique of
their society, and to espouse a contrarian, pessimistic view of human nature and of the possibility
of political reform that contrasts with the greater optimism of Enlightenment philosophes.
In Chapter One I argue that eighteenth-century moralistes chose to write in this genre in
order to use its concern with the limitations of moral language, and its valorization of clarity,
novelty, and piquancy, to focus on negative moral critiques of their society’s vices and
hypocrisies, without offering positive, didactic ethical guidance.
Chapter Two seeks to understand what eighteenth-century moralistes believe is the source of ethical ideas. While seventeenth-century moralistes shared similar theological and
philosophical beliefs, eighteenth-century moralistes adopt a broad range of positions in these
domains. However, I contend that eighteenth-century moralistes are ultimately united by their
belief that the sources of humans’ ethical impulses lie in nature, the passions, and the heart.
In Chapter Three, I examine the eighteenth-century moralistes’ ideas about the morality
of revolution. I maintain that despite the eighteenth-century moralistes’ extremely varied
political positions, all are undergirded by the same political impulse: each moraliste claims the mantle of the lone, principled contrarian, steadfastly defending the morally correct point of view against a more powerful opponent, be this the monarch or the mass of the people. Each
eighteenth-century moraliste believes he represents reason, justice, and the righteous minority,
even as each moraliste has different ideas about the moral permissibility of revolt against the government.
This dissertation thus argues that eighteenth-century moraliste writing elaborates an
alternative form and content of ethical writing in the Enlightenment era. The moralistes counter
the philosophes’ optimism about the goodness of human nature and the possibility of political reform by offering a negative, critical moral discourse that attacks their society’s hypocrisy and
that claims that only a few individuals of strong character may retain their moral clarity amid
society’s corruption.
Terms of Use
This article is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of-use#LAACitable link to this page
https://nrs.harvard.edu/URN-3:HUL.INSTREPOS:37372284
Collections
- FAS Theses and Dissertations [6566]
Contact administrator regarding this item (to report mistakes or request changes)