DASH
Repository logo
Communities & Collections
Browse DASH
DASH Stories
Statistics
  1. Home
  2. Faculty of Arts and Sciences
  3. FAS Theses and Dissertations
  4. Toward Robust and Transparent Estimation of the Effects of Time-dependent Interventions

Toward Robust and Transparent Estimation of the Effects of Time-dependent Interventions

Open/View files
Toward Robust and Transparent Estimation of the Effects of Time-dependent Interventions_v1.pdf (17.48 MB)
Date
May 10, 2024
Author(s)
Li, Yige
The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you.
Citation
Li, Yige. 2024. Toward Robust and Transparent Estimation of the Effects of Time-dependent Interventions. Doctoral dissertation, Harvard University Graduate School of Arts and Sciences.
Abstract
In real-world scenarios and within the causal inference framework, interventions may vary over time. The causal relationships between time-dependent interventions and outcomes are widely discussed across various fields such as medical science, health science, and social science. However, despite extensive research on this topic, there are still unresolved questions regarding improving estimation approaches for the causal effects of time-dependent interventions. Even in this era of big data, analyses of longitudinal studies frequently encounter limitations due to insufficient information when attempting to estimate these effects. Inspired by these challenges, we conduct three case studies on intervention evaluation and strive to obtain stable, efficient, robust, and transparent effect estimates. Below are summaries of each chapter, with their connections further discussed in the Introduction section. Chapter 1. During the early phase of the COVID-19 pandemic, we curated an integrated dataset from Chile (March 3 through June 15, 2020) and applied an augmented synthetic control method to estimate the effect of localized lockdowns under interference, disentangling their direct and indirect causal effects on SARS-CoV-2 transmission. Our results show that the effects of localized lockdowns are strongly modulated by their duration and the lockdown statuses of neighboring geographic areas. While extending localized lockdowns can slow the pandemic’s progression, our analysis suggests that such intervention alone is insufficient to curb contagion, especially when neighboring areas not under lockdown contribute to transmission. These empirical insights also shed light on the varied effectiveness of localized lockdowns across different geographic areas. Chapter 2. To adjust time-varying covariates in a transparent way for estimating treatment effects, we provide a longitudinal stable balancing weighting (LSBW) approach, building from the work in Resa Juárez (2017). This approach regularizes weights by minimizing their variation while ensuring covariate balance to acquire consistency and asymptotically normal estimators. This novel procedure gains efficiency by prioritizing balancing the functional forms of time-varying covariates that influence the outcome. Through the dual form of the optimization problem, the weights converge to the true inverse propensities and guarantee robustness to the misspecification of those functional forms. In a practical application, we use LSBW in a longitudinal observational study investigating the impact of attending private voucher school versus public school on students’ language and math scores in university admission tests in Chile. Our results show that entering a private voucher school has a significant positive effect on students’ academic outcomes and uncover that switching school types midway through the educational journey has a detrimental and accumulative impact on students’ performance. Chapter 3. To improve the estimation of the effects of static time-varying treatment regimes by selecting from candidate weighted estimators, we present a unifying framework from the standpoint of covariate balance for the g-computation formula, inverse probability weighting (IPW), augmented IPW, some of their variants, and LSBW from Chapter 2. We show the interconnections and distinctions among these methods by homologating them as weighting approaches. Each weighted estimator exhibits distinct performance under condition violations, resulting in varying mean error losses and asymptotic behaviors. To evaluate weighted estimators, we propose a diagnostic procedure based on covariate imbalance and weights distribution. In a case study, we analyze the effects of drug use on psychopathic traits among justice-involved male adolescents and find the average effects are neither additive nor monotonic. The findings indicate that among all the possible exposure pathways, the drug relapse pattern, on average, leads to the most adverse outcome for the male adolescents in the study.
Terms of Use
This article is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material (LAA), as set forth at Terms of Service
URI
https://nrs.harvard.edu/URN-3:HUL.INSTREPOS:37378820
Subjects

Causal Inference

Covariate Balancing

Interference

Longitudinal Studies

Time-varying Treatmen...

Unification

Biostatistics

Collection
FAS Theses and Dissertations
Metrics
Repository logo
  • CONTACT US
  • OSRDS
  • ABOUT DASH
  • DEPOSITING TO DASH
  • TERMS OF USE
  • REQUEST A WAIVER
  • TAKE DOWN POLICY
  • NAME CHANGE POLICY
  • HARVARD OA POLICIES
  • DASH SUBMITTER AGREEMENT
  • Accessibility
  • Privacy
Creative Commons License BY
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

Except where otherwise noted, this work is subject to a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License,
which allows anyone to share and adapt our material as long as proper attribution is given.
For details and exceptions, see the Harvard Library Copyright Policy
©2024 Presidents and Fellows of Harvard College.