DASH
Repository logo
Communities & Collections
Browse DASH
DASH Stories
Statistics
  1. Home
  2. Faculty of Arts and Sciences
  3. FAS Theses and Dissertations
  4. Teacher Talk in Middle School History: Differences Across Instructional Conditions and Their Impact on Seventh Graders’ Learning

Teacher Talk in Middle School History: Differences Across Instructional Conditions and Their Impact on Seventh Graders’ Learning

Open/View files
Andreev_Dissertation_Final Submission.pdf (3.16 MB)
Date
September 5, 2025
Author(s)
Andreev, Linda
The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you.
Citation
Andreev, Linda. 2025. Teacher Talk in Middle School History: Differences Across Instructional Conditions and Their Impact on Seventh Graders’ Learning. Doctoral Dissertation, Harvard University Graduate School of Arts and Sciences.
Abstract
Middle school social studies classrooms present unique challenges and opportunities for promoting disciplinary understanding and school-relevant language for all students in linguistically diverse settings. Discussion-based pedagogies have been shown to support student learning in these contexts, but, besides being underused, the hypothesis that teacher talk might mediate this relation remains untested. Thus, this dissertation developed and applied the History Teacher Talk Coding System (HTT), a novel instrument for analyzing the quantity and quality of cross-disciplinary and history-specific teacher talk through three key levers of responsive instruction for linguistically diverse classrooms: general discussion, historical reasoning, and language development. The data for this dissertation’s three studies are drawn from two randomized control trials (RCTs) testing the World Generation (WorldGen) discussion-based social studies curriculum in classrooms serving large proportions of Emergent Bilinguals (Capin et al., under preparation; Martinez et al., 2024). The WorldGen studies featured a within-teacher design, in which teachers’ seventh-grade classes were randomly assigned to either treatment or comparison (i.e., teachers’ typical) instruction. Study 1 developed the HTT and examined its sensitivity for detecting variability in teacher talk. Line-by-line coding of teachers’ instruction across instructional conditions indicated that the HTT was sensitive to differences in teacher talk by condition, teacher, and lesson. Teachers facilitated greater and richer use of General Discussion and Historical Reasoning moves during treatment lessons; however, little variation was noted in Vocabulary Instruction across conditions. In Study 2, I applied the HTT to a larger sample. Findings revealed that—relative to comparison instruction—when teachers used WorldGen, they and their students engaged in more Instructional Talk, and teachers fostered greater discussion, provided additional scaffolding for historical reasoning, and increased student-centered vocabulary instruction. Finally, in Study 3, I used hierarchical linear modeling to replicate the WorldGen intervention’s main effects and test whether the quantity and quality (both frequency and diversity) of teacher talk mediated the intervention’s effects on students’ content knowledge, vocabulary, and disciplinary literacy (i.e., historical thinking). Treatment effects replicated those in the larger RCT, and the quantity and, particularly, the quality of teacher talk mediated the curriculum’s impact on students’ content and language outcomes. Altogether, this dissertation offers a novel methodological tool that has generated empirical evidence for advancing the field’s understanding of discussion-rich, linguistically responsive teaching in social studies. These findings underscore the mediating effect of high-quality, multidimensional teacher talk on the simultaneous development of students’ content knowledge and language proficiency.
Terms of Use
This article is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material (LAA), as set forth at Terms of Service
URI
https://dash.harvard.edu/handle/1/42744141
Subjects

coding scheme

discussion

history

instruction and teach...

language and literacy...

teacher talk

Education

Collection
FAS Theses and Dissertations
Metrics
Repository logo
  • CONTACT US
  • OSRDS
  • ABOUT DASH
  • DEPOSITING TO DASH
  • TERMS OF USE
  • REQUEST A WAIVER
  • TAKE DOWN POLICY
  • NAME CHANGE POLICY
  • HARVARD OA POLICIES
  • DASH SUBMITTER AGREEMENT
  • Accessibility
  • Privacy
Creative Commons License BY
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

Except where otherwise noted, this work is subject to a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License,
which allows anyone to share and adapt our material as long as proper attribution is given.
For details and exceptions, see the Harvard Library Copyright Policy
©2024 Presidents and Fellows of Harvard College.